Email List

WEDDING GIVEAWAYCBS12 RADARROAD TRIPPINCBS NEWS LIVESUN SENTINELCRIME TRACKER
WPEC:: News - Health Care Reform

FACT CHECK: Truth takes a holiday on both sides of Obamacare debate

WASHINGTON -- President Barack Obama promises nothing will change for people who like their health coverage except it'll become more affordable, but the facts don't back him up. Mitt Romney groundlessly calls the health care law a slayer of jobs certain to deepen the national debt.

Welcome to the health care debate 2.0. As the claims fly, buyer beware.

After the Supreme Court upheld the law last week, Obama stepped forward to tell Americans what good will come from it. Romney was quick to lay out the harm. But some of the evidence they gave to the court of public opinion was suspect.

A look at their claims and how they compare with the facts:

---

OBAMA: "If you're one of the more than 250 million Americans who already have health insurance, you will keep your health insurance. This law will only make it more secure and more affordable."

ROMNEY: "Obamacare also means that for up to 20 million Americans, they will lose the insurance they currently have, the insurance that they like and they want to keep."

THE FACTS: Nothing in the law ensures that people happy with their policies now can keep them. Employers will continue to have the right to modify coverage or even drop it, and some are expected to do so as more insurance alternatives become available to the population under the law. Nor is there any guarantee that coverage will become cheaper, despite the subsidies many people will get.

Americans may well end up feeling more secure about their ability to obtain and keep coverage once insurance companies can no longer deny, terminate or charge more for coverage for those in poor health. But particular health insurance plans will have no guarantee of ironclad security. Much can change, including the cost.

The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office has estimated that the number of workers getting employer-based coverage could drop by several million, as some workers choose new plans in the marketplace or as employers drop coverage altogether. Companies with more than 50 workers would have to pay a fine for terminating insurance, but in some cases that would be cost-effective for them.

Obama's soothing words for those who are content with their current coverage have been heard before, rendered with different degrees of accuracy. He's said nothing in the law requires people to change their plans, true enough. But the law does not guarantee the status quo for anyone, either.

So where does Romney come up with 20 million at risk of losing their current plans?

He does so by going with the worst-case scenario in the budget office's analysis. Researchers thought it most likely that employer coverage would decline by 3 to 5 million, but the range of possibilities was broad: It could go up by as much as 3 million or down by as much as 20 million.

---

ROMNEY: After saying the new law cuts Medicare by $500 billion and raises taxes by a like amount, adds: "And even with those cuts and tax increases, Obamacare adds trillions to our deficits and to our national debt, and pushes those obligations onto coming generations."

THE FACTS: In its most recent complete estimate, in March 2011, the Congressional Budget Office said the new health care law would actually reduce the federal budget deficit by $210 billion over the next 10 years. In the following decade, the law would continue to reduce deficits by about one-half of one percent of the nation's gross domestic product, the office said.

The congressional budget scorekeepers acknowledged their projections are "quite uncertain" because of the complexity of the issue and the assumptions involved, which include the assumption that all aspects of the law are implemented as written. But the CBO assessment offers no backup for Romney's claim that the law "adds trillions to our deficits."

---

OBAMA: "And by this August, nearly 13 million of you will receive a rebate from your insurance company because it spent too much on things like administrative costs and CEO bonuses and not enough on your health care."

THE FACTS: Rebates are coming, but not nearly that many Americans are likely to get those checks and for many of those who do, the amount will be decidedly modest.

The government acknowledges it does not know how many households will see rebates in August from a provision of the law that makes insurance companies give back excess money spent on overhead instead of health care delivery. Altogether, the rebates that go out will benefit nearly 13 million people. But most of the benefit will be indirect, going to employers because they cover most of the cost of insurance provided in the workplace.

Employers can plow all the rebate money, including the workers' share, back into the company's health plan, or pass along part of it.

The government says some 4 million people who are due rebates live in households that purchased coverage directly from an insurance company, not through an employer, and experts say those households are the most likely to get a rebate check directly.

The government says the rebates have an average value of $151 per household. But employers, who typically pay 70 to 80 percent of premiums, are likely to get most of that.

---

ROMNEY: "Obamacare raises taxes on the American people by approximately $500 billion."

THE FACTS: The tax increases fall heavily on upper-income people, health insurance companies, drug makers and medical device manufacturers.

People who fail to obtain health insurance as required by the law will face a tax penalty, although that's expected to hit relatively few because the vast majority of Americans have insurance and many who don't will end up getting it. Also, a 10 percent tax has been imposed on tanning bed use as part of the health care law. There are no other across-the-board tax increases in the law, although some tax benefits such as flexible savings accounts are scaled back. Of course, higher taxes on businesses can be passed on to the consumer in the form of higher prices.

Individuals making over $200,000 and couples making over $250,000 will pay 0.9 percent more in Medicare payroll tax and a 3.8 percent tax on investments. As well, a tax starts in 2018 on high-value insurance plans.

---

OBAMA: "Because of the Affordable Care Act, young adults under the age of 26 are able to stay on their parents' health care plans, a provision that's already helped 6 million young Americans."

THE FACTS: Obama is overstating this benefit of his health law, and his own administration knows better. The Department of Health and Human Services, in a June 19 news release, said 3.1 million young adults would be uninsured were it not for the new law. Obama's number comes from a June 8 survey by the Commonwealth Fund, a health policy foundation. It said 6.6 million young adults joined or stayed on their parents' health plans who wouldn't have been able to absent the law. But that number includes some who switched to their parents' plans from other coverage, Commonwealth Fund officials told the Los Angeles Times.

---

ROMNEY: "Obamacare is a job-killer."

THE FACTS: The CBO estimated in 2010 that the law would reduce the amount of labor used in the economy by roughly half a percent.

But that's mostly because the law will give many people the opportunity to retire, stay at home with family or switch to part-time work, since they will be able to get health insurance more easily outside of their jobs. That voluntary retreat from the workforce, made possible by the law's benefits, is not the same as employers slashing jobs because of the law's costs, as Romney implies.

The law's penalties on employers who don't provide health insurance might cause some companies to hire fewer low-wage workers or to hire more part-timers instead of full-time employees, the budget office said. But the main consequence would still be from more people choosing not to work.

Apart from the budget office and other disinterested parties that study the law, each side in the debate uses research sponsored by interest groups, often slanted, to buttress its case. Romney cites a Chamber of Commerce online survey in which nearly three-quarters of respondents said the law would dampen their hiring.

The chamber is a strong opponent of the law, having run ads against it. Its poll was conducted unscientifically and is therefore not a valid measure of business opinion.FACT CHECK: Truth takes a holiday on both sides of Obamacare debate

Tuesday, July 3 2012, 09:30 AM EDT

Links

Share your health care reform questions & challenged with new health care laws.

Name
Location
Question


 
  • WPEC :: News - Road Trippin

    Road Trippin

    Come Road Trippin' with us!
  • WPEC :: News - The Greek's Trifecta

    The Greek's Trifecta

    Prognostication, travel and women are The Greek's strong suits as well as his vices. Listen as The Greek breaks down the lines on the biggest games of the week for CBS12.
  • WPEC :: News - In Your Corner

    In Your Corner

    CBS12 News has Florida Gov. Rick Scott "In Your Corner," answering your questions. Ask a question in the Facebook commenting window below or email it to newstips@cbs12.com.
  • WPEC :: News - Town Hall

    Town Hall

    Watch the Aug. 23, 2012 town hall meeting on issues affecting South Florida.
  • WPEC :: News - Spot Crime

    Spot Crime

    Search for any crime within a 5-mile radius of your home!
  • WPEC :: News - Health Care Reform

    Health Care Reform

    The Supreme Court ruling to uphold the Affordable Care Act sparked a new battle. Check here daily for the latest developments, locally and across the country.
  • WPEC :: News - Trending with Tracy

    Trending with Tracy

    Tracy St. George, a South Florida DJ for WRMF, delivers the hottest celebrity news weekly on CBS12's Trending with Tracy.

  • WPEC :: News - CBS12 Dolphins Extra

    CBS12 Dolphins Extra

    Get the inside scoop on the Miami Dolphins with CBS12's Josh Samuels and Pat Murphy.
  • WPEC :: News - Wednesday's Weather Kid

    Wednesday's Weather Kid

    Welcome to Wednesday's Weather Kid on CBS12's Good Morning South Florida! Here we let middle schoolers produce a "bus stop forecast" each Wednesday. Contact Robin Cross at rcross@cbs12.com for info on ...
  • WPEC :: News - Washington Guardian

    Washington Guardian

    The Washington Guardian is an online newspaper committed to providing watchdog journalism from the nation's capital aimed at safeguarding everyday Americans' tax dollars, security and freedoms.
  • WPEC :: News - Your Voice. Your Future.

    Your Voice. Your Future.

    As the country faces challenges from federal budget issues to jobs and national debt, your voice is critical to the future.
  • WPEC :: News - Waste Watch

    Waste Watch

    How are your tax dollars being spent? Waste Watch tracks whether local, state and federal governments or any groups are using your money wisely...or wasting it.
  • WPEC :: News - Top Stories

    Top Stories

    Get up to the minute information from South Florida and the Treasure Coast in our Top Stories section!
  • WPEC :: News - Newscast Links

    Newscast Links

    Get links and contact information from items mentioned in our newscasts!
  • WPEC :: News - Tech-Xperts

    Tech-Xperts

    Get tips and advice on everything tech related, from smartphones, gadgets and online security to Twitter topics and Facebook news and tips!
  • WPEC :: News - Treasure Coast

    Treasure Coast

    Watch local news videos and read news stories happening in Treasure Coast!
  • WPEC :: News - Palm Beach County

    Palm Beach County

    Watch local news videos and read news stories happening in Palm Beach County!
  • WPEC :: News - News Tips

    News Tips

    Do you have a lead on a good news tip or want to share a story idea? Let us know!
  • WPEC :: News - Raw News

    Raw News

    See the news as it happened, raw and unedited!
  • WPEC :: News - CBS 12 News LIVE Stream

    CBS 12 News LIVE Stream

    Watch LIVE CBS 12 newscasts and breaking news as it happens here!
  • WPEC :: News - Traffic Links

    Traffic Links

    Get links and information on traffic conditions, rail information and arrival and departure information for PBIA, MIA and FLL!
  • WPEC :: News - PBC Mugshot Roundup

    PBC Mugshot Roundup

    View a selection of mugshots from the Palm Beach County Jail's portrait studio, via a publicly available online booking search.
  • WPEC :: News - Sex Offender Mapping

    Sex Offender Mapping

    Search for any registered sexual offender or predator within a 5-mile radius of your home!
  • WPEC :: News - Product Recalls

    Product Recalls

    Get the latest recalls on autos, child safety seats, consumer products and FDA food and drugs recalls!
  • WPEC :: News - Forever Family

    Forever Family

    Watch videos and read stories of local people and families in need!
  • WPEC :: News - The Dwyer Awards

    The Dwyer Awards

    The William T. Dwyer Awards for Excellence in Education honors outstanding educators from public and private schools in Palm Beach County.


  • WPEC :: News - Live Feed

    Live Feed

    Watch the CBS News Live Feed for news stories as they happen!
  • WPEC :: News - National and World News

    National and World News

    Get the latest headlines from across the nation and around the world.
  • WPEC :: News - Pet of the Day

    Pet of the Day

    Watch our "Pet of the Day" videos for adorable pets that need a loving home!
  • WPEC :: News - Pump Patrol

    Pump Patrol

    Find the lowest gas prices in West Palm Beach, get fuel saving tips, price trends and check out nationwide gas price averages!

more »

Tonight on CBS12

8:00 PM
NCIS

9:00 PM
NCIS: Los Angeles

10:00 PM
Vegas
Complete Schedule»